7 Things Bad Leaders Tell Themselves and Their Teams


Carey Nieuwhof explains that ineffective leaders tend to lay the blame on seven common excuses. Successful leaders are aware of these traps and lead people beyond them.

Nobody sets out to be a bad leader. You didn’t. I didn’t. Yet according to a Gallup study, only 18% of managers have a “high degree of talent” in leading people, which includes the ability to motivate and manage the relationships they have with people around them. So why does the world end up with so many not-so-great leaders?

Often those of us who lead lack the self-awareness to know when we’re leading poorly. Leadership is difficult. You have to overcome obstacles that non-leaders never tackle, and then you have to lead other people over those obstacles. Also, your first approach to a problem usually isn’t the right one.

Has bad thinking clouded your ability to lead effectively? Here are seven things bad leaders say to themselves and to their teams.

1. “If I’m going to get it done right, I have to do it myself.”

We’ve all been frustrated with the work other people do. After trying numerous times and maybe even after working with numerous people, it’s very tempting to conclude that no one can do the job but me. That’s fabulous thinking if you want to keep your organization tiny and never scale it beyond your own personal abilities. It’s also fabulous thinking if you believe you are the only person God gifted in your organization. But if you want to grow, it’s a terrible way to lead. And it’s completely demotivating for the people around you.

The inability to do great things through others can usually be tied to a lack of clarity on your part as a leader. If others aren’t doing their jobs well, there’s a good chance it’s because you never explained what success looks like. There’s also a very good chance the definition of success you carry is 100 percent in your head; you’ve never written anything down. Or what you have written down is so general or vague it’s not helpful. You can’t hold people accountable for something you never explained to them. Yet most leaders try anyway. Clarity is a hallmark of great leadership. If your team isn’t measuring up, there’s a very good chance you haven’t been clear.

2. “My job would be perfect if it weren’t for people.”

Yes, leading people is the most challenging aspect of leadership. Leading people is going to tax you more than almost anything. Leadership is difficult because leaders take people where they wouldn’t ordinarily go. Think about that for a moment. That’s hard! But please realize that as much as you joke that your job would be easy if it weren’t for other people, you wouldn’t have a job if there weren’t other people. If you’re honest, when you’re mad at others you’re often really mad at yourself and your inability to lead them. Figure out how to lead better, and you won’t be nearly as mad at people as you used to be.

3. “Listen …,”

What do you do when you feel like you’re losing control in leadership? You try to take control. You say things like “Listen …, I’ve been at this a long time and …” Ever notice people who start sentences with “Listen” rarely listen? And when you stop listening, you shut down everyone else in the room. They instinctively think, “Well, he’s not listening anymore so it doesn’t matter what I say or ask.” Instead of trying to take control, ask a question instead, like “Is anything unclear?” or “So what are people thinking?” It’s far better.

4. “I’m having trouble with your colleague.”

Every leader gets frustrated. The question is, what do you do with that frustration? Bad leaders complain about the team to the members of the team. Big mistake. When your team hears you speak poorly about someone else on the team, trust dissipates as quickly as a mist in the desert sun. The team knows that if you’re talking smack about their colleague, you’re probably talking poorly to others about them as well.

Every leader needs a safe place to vent. Cultivate that. But do that intentionally. Have a small team around you where you can solve your problems and talk honestly. If you don’t have a small circle of trusted people with whom you can solve problems, your frustration will leak out all over and do damage that can be difficult or impossible to repair. Never complain about the team to the team if you want a great team.

5. “At least we’re doing better than (fill in the blank.)”

If that’s your standard, get a new standard. Please.

6. “My people won’t let me.”

I hear this all the time: My people won’t let me spend money on leadership coaching. My people won’t let me change the way we do music. My people won’t allow us to consider that kind of ministry.

Your people won’t let you? Really? Hey, when you were four years old, your mom wouldn’t let you do things. But you’re not four anymore. There’s so much wrong with the “‘my people won’t let me” stance. First, you just threw your entire crew under the bus. Second, you’re the leader. So, lead them. (If you can’t lead them effectively enough to change people, stop blaming them and look in the mirror.) Third, if the change you want to bring about is unsuccessful for now, respect that. Back your people in public. Back them in private. Love them. Love doesn’t always mean agreement. Love doesn’t always mean you feel deep affection for them in every moment. But love and respect are linked. And you don’t throw people you love under the bus. If you can’t love your people, stop leading them.

7. “Failure is not an option.”

The only way failure is not an option is if you risk nothing. And, ironically, if you risk nothing, failure also becomes inevitable. If you’re going to innovate, you have to fail. If you don’t learn to fail, you’ll never truly succeed. As Winston Churchill said, success is moving from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm. Exactly.

This material is reprinted by permission from careynieuwhof.com. The original post can be found at 7 Things Bad Leaders Tell Themselves and Their Teams.

Related Resources


About Author

Photo of Carey Nieuwhof

Carey Nieuwhof is founding and teaching pastor of Connexus Community Church in Barrie, Ontario, Canada; a popular blogger and podcaster; and author of bestselling books. Visit his website at CareyNieuwhof.com.

Cover of Discovering God's Future for Your Church showing a blank wooden signpostLewis Center video tool kit resource
Discovering God’s Future for Your Church

Discovering God’s Future for Your Church is a turn-key tool kit to help your congregation discern and implement God’s vision for its future. The resource guides your church in discovering clues to your vision in your history and culture, your current congregational strengths and weaknesses, and the needs of your surrounding community. The tool kit features videos, leader’s guides, discussion exercises, planning tools, handouts, diagrams, worksheets, and more. Learn more and watch an introductory video now.