Congregational Leadership in Difficult Times


What would your congregation’s worship service look like next Sunday if your sanctuary burned to the ground tomorrow, if a beloved pastor announced that he or she was retiring suddenly, if a scandal came to light, or if another unexpected catastrophe like September 11th occurred? The thesis of Kathleen Smith’s book is: When congregations go through difficult times, those difficulties affect the worship life of the congregation, and the practice of worship will itself be a key part of the congregation’s healing process. The text explores how worship can be a vital avenue of pastoral care when congregations go through times of crisis, transition, and conflict.

Careful planning and deliberate preparation are essential in turbulent times — but they are also extremely difficult when one is caught in the throes of chaos. Smith has carefully outlined questions and options to keep worship leaders focused. Much of the book is devoted to identifying appropriate liturgical resources for difficult times and suggesting many helpful theological themes, scriptures, prayers, and hymns.

StillingStormCoverBut the book rightly acknowledges that finding the best prayer or the most fitting passage does not alone guarantee that worship will help a congregation through difficult times. Some of the book’s most valuable information comes in the final chapter, which considers the role and responsibility of congregational leaders in challenging times. Effective leaders know themselves and their congregation. They manage their own feelings in difficult times and work to keep all channels of communication open. They take great care in choosing the words they use — particularly in worship. Leaders have the opportunity to model the appropriate tone and language that will help the congregation move forward.

Leaders should expect that dealing with hard times will be painful. But with humility and faith in the power of God to still the storm, they can guide troubled churches toward healing, reconciliation, and forgiveness.

Stilling the Storm by Kathleen S. Smith of the Alban Institute, can be purchased at Amazon


About Author

Ann A. Michel is associate director of the Lewis Center for Church Leadership of Wesley Theological Seminary and teaches in the areas of stewardship and leadership. She is also the author of Synergy: A Leadership Guide for Church Staff and Volunteers (Abingdon, 2017), available at Cokesbury and Amazon.

Person standing amongst colorful autumn trees and gazing upwardNEW Video-based Adult Christian Study
Nature: Our First Way of Knowing God

This seven-session video-based adult Christian study awakens our visceral knowing of the Creator through the creation, reconnects us with the sacred landscapes we call home, encourages us to provide space and time for spiritual reflection in nature, and helps us live in greater harmony with God’s earth.

Learn more, watch a video preview, and see sample Study Guide pages now.