Building Healthy Conflict Practices into Membership Vows


Jonathan Arnpriester helps avoid church conflict by including positive conflict values in new membership training and membership vows.

I have always struggled with the presence of seemingly unnecessary conflict in congregations. Some unhealthy behaviors, such as control issues and gossip, can be seen as individual personality problems. Yet, they can result in a systemic illness for the entire congregation. So how do we create conditions that encourage naturally occurring conflicts to be handled in a healthy manner?” or “How does a healthy church incorporate conflict?”

I found part of the answer in the questions of membership. We have actually incorporated questions about healthy congregational behaviors into “The Meaning of Membership at Mosaic.” Positive conflict values are part of membership training and are lifted up in worship every time we receive new members. The membership vows are in four parts: Prayers, Presence, Gifts, and Service. Notice the vows for Prayers:


  • We will pray for each other in all situations of life.
  • When there is conflict we will follow the direction of Jesus in Matthew — we will talk directly with the person with whom we have a problem. No triangulation.

It actually works. People will come and talk with me about their disagreements, often mentioning the membership vows. It also enables me to confront those who vent concerns behind the backs of the people with whom they are unhappy. I always begin the encounter by acknowledging that their concerns are linked to their love of the church and authentically recalling the specific ways their love of the church is made manifest. In each case, the person has apologized and we have been able to work to a resolution that is truly a blessing. Some of the persons I have had to confront have become my biggest supporters.

I have learned that God’s will for good can be done if leaders are willing to be vulnerable, trust people, see God in all people, and believe that all things can work for good.

Related Resources


About Author

Jonathan Arnpriester is pastor of Chandler United Methodist Church in Chandler, Arizona.

What is God's vision for your congregation?What Next Faithful Step is God Calling Your Church to Take?

Discovering God’s Future for Your Church is a new turn-key tool kit to help your congregation discern and implement God’s vision for its future. The resource guides your church in discovering clues to your vision in your history and culture, your current congregational strengths and weaknesses, and the needs of your surrounding community. The tool kit features videos, leader’s guides, discussion exercises, planning tools, handouts, diagrams, worksheets, and more. Learn more and watch an introductory video now.